Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn
    Tuesday, February 7
    Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn RSS
    Nalin Mehta
    • Home
    • The New BJP
    • Books
    • Columns
      • Politics & Current Affairs
      • Sports
      • Media
      • Public Policy
    • Videos
    • Research Articles
    • Media
    • About
    Nalin Mehta
    You are at:Home » Blog » Discontent in green
    Politics & Current Affairs

    Discontent in green

    Nalin MehtaBy Nalin MehtaAugust 13, 2012Updated:April 5, 2015No Comments5 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    The last time Samba was in the national headlines was when the Delhi High Court acquitted some of the accused officers from the infamous Samba spy case of the 1970s with full honours. That case is still being fought in the Supreme Court but for no fault of its own, this cantonment town near Jammu is now once again in the news for the wrong reasons with yet another unit showing afflicted with discontent.

    S what exactly happened in the 16 Light Cavalry Regiment and what does one make of it? A jawan gets a phone call, asks for leave in a state of emotional stress and commits suicide when it is denied. Angry jawans then confront officers forcing senior commanders to rush in and intervene. Is this an isolated case or can we see this as yet another example of a general decline in the army’s standards of discipline, leadership and order? Why shouldnt we, especially as this incident comes just two months after the terrible standoff between officers and their men in an artillery regiment in Leh? Are we now seeing a pattern of officers losing control, of soldiers being more rebellious and the army becoming a less cohesive force? Is the last great standing institution of the indian state, one that remains a neutral bulwarks of the nation’s foundations, now on a trajectory of irreversible decline?

    The army is certainly at a crossroads but it is important to see the Samba case in context. First, suicides in the uniformed services, with the stresses of long distance relationships and the restrictions on family housing, even in peace stations, are not new. This was always an ugly underbelly of the Army except that a lot more news comes out into the open now.

    Secondly, any army is a product of the society it serves and the social context around the army has long changed. The old army model of cantonments was predicated on a principle of isolation; the cantonments were designed to be islands, separated from the chaos of rest of the country, content in their order and in their discipline. As our cities have expanded, most Cantonments are not outside the city limits any more, but well within them. The physical shrinking of distance between the army and the world outside has been complimented by an even larger disruption: the cellphone and the information revolution which means that soldiers are now much more connected to the outside world, their families and the pressures and pulls of society outside their self enclosed regimental walls.

    With the splendid isolation of old gone and aspiration levels in its rank and file rising higher, the changing social matrix demands higher and more sophisticated levels of leadership but precisely at the time when this is most needed, we have had a steady deterioration of the officer class speeded up by a governmental neglect so malignant that it has now reached a serious crisis point.

    At its heart this is a question of status and standing. Notions of izzat and hour are the backbone of the defence services and we expect our soldiers to be above the general rut that afflicts the police, the bureaucracy and the other arms of the state. Yet, how can you expect a soldier to adhere to a different code when we ourselves don’t give them their due: in terms of honour, status and remuneration.

    Take for example, the anomalies in the Sixth Pay Commission which have created real disparities between the army and other services. The most glaring of these is the grant of what bureaucrats callnon-functional upgradation to officers in Group A organised services under the central government. To simplify a complex issue, in layman terms this means that Group A officers can now be awarded the grade pay and allowances of IAS officers with a two year delay but not army officers.

    This gradual erosion of the defence services in the pecking order of official India has been on for decades but as long as the Army continued to be isolated from the rest of society it was manageable. Now with greater integration and much more openness of information, such disparities are one to lead to a general sense of discontent and malaise.

    We will only get the soldiers we pay for and the time has come for a course correction. A professional Amy deserves to be treated professionally and not excluded from higher decision making. The Naresh Chandra committee has forcefuly recommended a new beginning by integrating the armed forces in to the defence ministry and personnel issues such ‘one rank one pay’ cannot be allowed to hang forever

    Manmohan Singh would have many things in his mind as he prepares his ninth independence day speech but none with such far reaching consequences as the wider sense of despair and neglect in india’s armed forces. Surely, time has come to act.

    Army defence military
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleBeijing 2008: A Watershed for Indian Sport
    Next Article Contradictory trends in Indian television
    Nalin Mehta
    • Website
    • Twitter

    Professor Nalin Mehta is Dean, School of Modern Media, UPES; Advisor, Global University Systems and Non-Resident Senior Fellow, Institute of South Asian Studies, National University Singapore. He is an award-winning social scientist, journalist and author who has held senior leadership positions in major Indian media companies; international financing institutions like the Global Fund in Geneva, Switzerland; taught and held research positions at universities and institutions in Australia (ANU, La Trobe University), Singapore (NUS), Switzerland (International Olympic Museum) and India (IIM Bangalore, Shiv Nadar University).

    Related Posts

    Gujarat Elections: The story behind BJP’s record win and what’s next for Congress

    December 13, 2022

    The Roots of Brand Modi: 5 Reasons Why the BJP Keeps Winning Elections

    December 13, 2022

    In Gujarat elections, a battle of prestige

    December 7, 2022

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Tags
    2002 riots Army Asian Games BJP BSP China Commonwealth Games communal violence Congress corruption Cricket defence Delhi diplomacy education Godhra Gujarat Hindutva hockey Indian Army internal security international relations IPL Kashmir Mayawati media and politics military Modi Narendra Modi Nehru Olympics OROP Pakistan Parliament politics of sports Punjab Rahul Gandhi RBI Rio 2016 television terrorism United States UP Uttar Pradesh West Bengal
    Archives
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    Don't Miss

    Important Statement By RSS Chief Mohan Bhagwat

    Sangh-bjp Kinship On A Good Wicket

    BJP Creates History In Gujarat

    GujaratElection2022 BJP touches 150 leads! Roots of this victory built on cadre mobilization

    About

    Professor Nalin Mehta is Dean, School of Modern Media, UPES; Advisor, Global University Systems an Non-Resident Senior Fellow, Institute of South Asian Studies, National University Singapore. He is an award-winning social scientist, journalist and author who has held senior leadership positions in major Indian digital, print and TV news companies; been a communications expert with international financing institutions and the UN in Geneva, Switzerland; taught and held research positions at universities and institutions in Australia, Singapore, Switzerland and India.

    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn RSS
    Recent Posts

    Important Statement By RSS Chief Mohan Bhagwat

    February 3, 2023

    Sangh-bjp Kinship On A Good Wicket

    February 3, 2023

    BJP Creates History In Gujarat

    December 13, 2022
    Tweets by ‎@nalinmehta

    Tweets by nalinmehta

    Copyright © 2023
    • Home
    • The New BJP
    • Books
    • Columns
      • Politics & Current Affairs
      • Sports
      • Media
      • Public Policy
    • Videos
    • Research Articles
    • Media
    • About

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.