Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn
    Monday, May 19
    Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn RSS
    Nalin Mehta
    • Home
    • The New BJP
    • Books
    • Columns
      • Politics & Current Affairs
      • Sports
      • Public Policy
    • Videos
    • Research Articles
    • In The Media
    • About
    Nalin Mehta
    You are at:Home » Blog » Britain has had its Chilcot, India should have its Hendersoon-Brooks
    Politics & Current Affairs

    Britain has had its Chilcot, India should have its Hendersoon-Brooks

    Nalin MehtaBy Nalin MehtaJuly 7, 2016Updated:July 9, 2016No Comments4 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Some British voters may already be having buyer’s remorse on voting to leave the EU, and British politicians have since made a mess of the post-Brexit confusion but there is one thing that Britain has done wonderfully well. The publication of its Chilcot report on its Iraq military misadventure, a damning and detailed report of inquiry on the UK’s involvement in the Iraq war authored by former civil servant Sir John Chilcot and his council of privy counsellors, is a refreshing step that shows a mirror to power and how the British public was misled into fighting a war that ultimately changed the world, destroying a country that had little to do with global terrorism and eventually creating the conditions that spawned IS.

    There is enough in there to damn then British prime minister Tony Blair. The report broadly finds that Tony Blair committed himself to then US President George W. Bush for an invasion almost eight months before receiving parliamentary and legal backing; the invasion was based on “flawed intelligence and assessments” that went unchallenged and that the UK was “undermining” the UN Security Council’s authority in the absence of majority support for military action. Chilcot’s report stops short of indicting Blair but concludes that “the circumstances in which it was decided that there was a legal basis for UK military action were far from satisfactory”.

    Confirming the poodle attitude that British foreign policy had adopted with the US, Blair sent a memo to George W. Bush in July 2002, saying “I will be with you, whatever.” This, says the report, made it “very difficult for the UK subsequently to withdraw its support” for the March 2003 invasion. Subsequently, the report says that prewar intelligence was basically doctored or misrepresented and British military strategies in Iraq were “wholly inadequate.” Tony Blair, of course has rejected this saying the report showed “no bad faith, lies or deceit”.

    Overall, the Chilcot report, prepared after seven years of investigation, is a damning indictment of an establishment that took Britain into a war that ultimately cost it over 9 billion pounds.

    Publishing such a report transparently is good in any democracy.

    Compare this with our own Henderson-Brooks report into the debacle of the 1962 war that still remains a state secret. The wounds of that war still colour our judgment on China. Understanding how we messed up so badly, the role of our disastrous “forward policy”, the problems with Defence Minister Krishna Menon and Nehru’s blind spots on defence management that condemned the Indian Army to an ignominious rout despite pockets of valiant resistance is important.

    Indian soldiers during the 1962 India-China war. (Getty Images photo)
    Indian soldiers during the 1962 India-China war. (Getty Images photo)
    Indian troops at a Ladakh border post during the 1962 India-China war. (Getty Images photo)
    Indian troops at a Ladakh border post during the 1962 India-China war. (Getty Images photo)

    Following the war, the Indian Army commissioned then Lt Gen Henderson Brooks and Brigadier P S Bhagat to study why we lost and learn lessons but all governments since have refrained from releasing its findings saying it was “extremely sensitive” and of “current operational value”.

    People fleeing in a train in Assam from the 1962 India-China war on November 1, 1962. (Getty Images photo)
    People fleeing in a train in Assam from the 1962 India-China war on November 1, 1962. (Getty Images photo)

    A purported copy was put out in early 2014 by 88-year old Australian journalist Neville Maxwell and it is still available online on the website of the Indian Defence Review.

    Yet, a full disclosure is essential. In opposition BJP had demanded the report’s release but in July 2014 the Modi government did a u-turn and refused to make the report public.

    The UK has released a damning report, warts and all, on a war that was fought only a decade ago. India as a country refuses to release a report on a war that was fought before the majority of today’s Indians were born.
    We should learn from the UK and put the 1962 report out.

    1962 war Chilcot China Henderson-Brooks Indian Army Iraq war Tony Blair
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleAfter Raghuram Rajan: Challenges for the Next RBI Governor
    Next Article Akhilesh Yadav’s second coming
    Nalin Mehta
    • Website
    • Twitter

    Professor Nalin Mehta is Dean, School of Modern Media, UPES; Advisor, Global University Systems and Non-Resident Senior Fellow, Institute of South Asian Studies, National University Singapore. He is an award-winning social scientist, journalist and author who has held senior leadership positions in major Indian media companies; international financing institutions like the Global Fund in Geneva, Switzerland; taught and held research positions at universities and institutions in Australia (ANU, La Trobe University), Singapore (NUS), Switzerland (International Olympic Museum) and India (IIM Bangalore, Shiv Nadar University).

    Related Posts

    BJP juggernaut and national politics: Seven takeaways for 2024 elections

    December 3, 2023

    Exit polls: Five takeaways for national politics on road to 2024

    November 30, 2023

    G20: India’s new soft power is digital public infrastructure

    September 11, 2023

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Tags
    2002 riots Army Asian Games BJP BSP China Commonwealth Games communal violence Congress corruption Cricket defence Delhi diplomacy education Gujarat hockey Indian Army internal security international relations IPL Kashmir Mayawati media and politics military Modi Nalin Mehta Narendra Modi Nehru Olympics OROP Pakistan Parliament politics of sports Punjab Rahul Gandhi RBI Rio 2016 television terrorism The New BJP United States UP Uttar Pradesh West Bengal
    Archives
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    Don't Miss

    BJP juggernaut and national politics: Seven takeaways for 2024 elections

    Exit polls: Five takeaways for national politics on road to 2024

    Notes and Appendices: The New BJP

    Emergence of a powerful PM was a turning point in India’s digital revolution

    About

    Professor Nalin Mehta is Dean, School of Modern Media, UPES; Advisor, Global University Systems an Non-Resident Senior Fellow, Institute of South Asian Studies, National University Singapore. He is an award-winning social scientist, journalist and author who has held senior leadership positions in major Indian digital, print and TV news companies; been a communications expert with international financing institutions and the UN in Geneva, Switzerland; taught and held research positions at universities and institutions in Australia, Singapore, Switzerland and India.

    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn RSS
    Recent Posts

    BJP juggernaut and national politics: Seven takeaways for 2024 elections

    December 3, 2023

    Exit polls: Five takeaways for national politics on road to 2024

    November 30, 2023

    Notes and Appendices: The New BJP

    November 6, 2023
    Tweets by ‎@nalinmehta

    Tweets by nalinmehta

    Copyright © 2025
    • Home
    • The New BJP
    • Books
    • Columns
      • Politics & Current Affairs
      • Sports
      • Public Policy
    • Videos
    • Research Articles
    • In The Media
    • About

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.